Posted by
When you work at a college and travel in academic circles you come across quite a few people for whom teaching is a distant plan B from plan A (writing), some of whom—not many, thankfully—make perfectly clear that their fondness for plan B is no greater than plan Q. I find this genuinely sad. While storytelling is my prime passion and writing my medium for expression, and I consider these my profession, in many ways the opportunities I have to teach are just as important to me. In some ways, certainly more important.
Thursday night I was reminded of this when I spoke to a chapter of the League of Utah Writers. I talked about networking, and people participated by asking questions, sharing stories, and making comments and recommendations. Like just about every instructional event I do, it was constructive and fun for me, as I hope it was others. I don’t have to try very hard to hope that, though, because of the expressions of appreciation and gratitude that followed the presentation, that night, here on my blog, and elsewhere. It’s very easy to convince yourself you’ve done something helpful when other people tell you so. And I can’t recall a single workshop or panel I’ve ever participated in that people haven’t thanked me for. I share this not merely to acknowledge the many kind people I get to meet, but to admit I’m just beginning to see how important this all is to my advancement as a writer. I don’t mean by broadening my name recognition and interest in my writing, though that is certainly true as well; for me, teaching others is a large part of what makes the writer’s life—my life—happy.
There are pitfalls for writers, like any artist, some darker and deeper than others. Addiction to self-destructive vehicles of distraction is always nearer than we think. Every good story goes places that no healthy person would ever want to travel emotionally; to get the story there, the writer has to go as well, if only in their mind. It’s no wonder that individuals who emotionally confront the darker aspects of human experience rather than retreat from them sometimes cope unhealthily. But not every pit is so insidious. Some, like feelings of rejection and loneliness, are common to all humans. It’s just that, for writers, these pits are so broad it’s incredibly difficult—if not impossible—to avoid them for much of your life.
Writing is, mostly, a solitary art. So is the contemplation it involves, the ruminating and daydreaming and asking yourself innumerable questions to which you have no answers. Success doesn’t change that. In a way, it only makes it worse. There is a special kind of loneliness in fame (a supposition of mine, as I’m as far from famous as one can get); in being marked and noted by mobs of people, none of whom know you at all beyond the brand you’ve come to embody. There is no escape, not completely. When you decide to become a writer, to do it full-hearted and regardless of cost or condition, you reconcile yourself to being a lonesome kind of person. Rejection is just as inescapable. In a flux so great as that of written story, where every person has the potent birthrights of language and narrative affinity; where these potentials tie together into a unique, subjective, and lovely snarl that we call a person; where mastery is so impossible you may write your whole life and send your skill not a jot higher but only sideways—in such a place, how can any of us expect to write and not be rejected, under appreciated, and misunderstood? It’s a great and terrible truth that every person is a mystery, even to one’s self. When we bump against each other in passing there is zero chance that our rough edges will always fit together. The best work we will ever do—could ever do—will not please all people. Sometimes when it does not, we will hear about it. We will hear.
Agents, editors, those who publish our work to world, they don’t want to reject us. But they will. Many, many times, they will.
We don’t desire to be away from people, alone and apart, to make our stories breathe. But we will be. For too much of our lives, we will be.
We can’t help but feel these things. I certainly can’t. Which is why, as much as any other reason, I love to teach. It fills my writer’s life with those things it so desperately lacks: society instead of solitude; mutual edification rather than private refinement; gratitude and immediate returns rather than form letters, criticisms, and the hollow ticking of the clock. If you are like me, a writer and storyteller for better and worse, then I offer one heartfelt suggestion: share that. Teach. Find something you know and do well and help others to know and do it too, still their way, only a little better than before. I have no doubts that your career, your quality of life, and your entirety of person will all improve if you do.
Thank you very much for this post. It embodies a lot of what I’ve been feeling, as I’m sure many others have been feeling. So thank you, once again, for your inspiring words of wisdom. I’ll be sure to come say hello at LTUE. See you soon!
Hi! I’m one of the people who attended the LUW meeting on networking. I wanted to thank you for your presentation there, and also for your comments at Rick Walton’s Wednesday night class at BYU. I’ve been writing for several years but recently switched genres so I’m trying to learn everything I can about writing fantasy. I appreciate you sharing very helpful your ideas.
I’ve attended a class of yours (and a personal workshop) so I can vouch for your teaching ability. You can teach up a storm, Clint. You can write too. See you at LTUE, where isn’t so solitary after all. =]
That was a very good presentation you gave on networking. I’m at the point right now where I’ve heard most of the writing do’s and don’ts, so this was very refreshing and different. I took notes and posted them on my blog: http://forgefire.blogspot.com/2010/01/dos-and-donts-of-networking.html
I know what you are talking about when you say writing is a solitary art. In music or painting, your audience can participate passively, but reading requires your audience to sit and spend time with your work–something that it is very difficult to get them to do. If I ever give people advice, I tell them to join a writer’s group. As a writer at any level, it’s often the only way you’ll get anyone at all to read your work.
It’s strange, isn’t it, the commonality that can be found in feelings of isolation…. Well, it’s part of the gig. I’ll look for you at LTUE.
I’m glad it was worth your time, Debbie. There’s a lot to writing fantasy, so learn from whatever source you can, but here’s the single most important lesson about transitioning genres: all good stories are far more similar than different. If you know how to write a truly good story, you can learn to write a good story in any genre. I hope to see you around in the future.
Thanks, L.T. I’m confident in my writing, I suppose. (I think the only writers who are always confident are delusional and egomaniacal.) But it’s easier to be confident in my teaching because of the wealth of positive immediate feedback I’ve received—like this comment! So thanks for always having a good word to say. I appreciate it.
Ah, Tom, you offer a fine—and anything but uncommon—example of how small professional spheres are with your tale from the realm of academia. That is a plane of existence with strange rules all its own. I’ve told numerous friends that I’m not a good candidate for an MFA, no matter what they say, because I’m far too opinionated and recalcitrant to make it that far without major bloodletting along the way—mine and other people’s.
As for other artistic mediums, you’re right that some allow better immediate feedback to the artist. Performative arts, certainly, and those designed to be processed in a concentrated amount of time. Talking shop is often the best we writers can do.
Hi Clint - Just wanted to let you know I appreciated both your time and your insights at the LUW chapter meeting last week. I’ve been so busy passing around your thoughts, second hand, to friends who didn’t make it to the meeting that I’ve been remiss about expressing my gratitude. Please forgive.
I did and do appreciate your advice. I took copious notes - because I’m an inveterate note taker and also because you had experience and information to share that was valuable to all of us who were willing to listen.
I also appreciated your encouragement out in the parking lot after the meeting. I am thinking about what you said. It’s funny how teaching in church or a public school doesn’t faze me but the idea of trying to teach something to people who know so much more than I do is terrifying. However, I also realize one learns by teaching so I will put a presentation together. It will be a good exercise for me. Now I’ll have to ‘gird up my loins, fresh courage take’ and think about actually giving the presentation once it’s assembled.
Thank you, again, for your advice and encouragement.